From creamy artisanal scoops at Sunni Sky’s to large soft-serve ice cones from Yarborough’s and magical homemade flavors from Gillis Hill Farm, there is an ice cream shop for everyone to enjoy during the summer season in Fayetteville! Whether you’re looking for classic favorites or more daring tastes, be sure to check the offerings of these well-known destinations.

Try Something New at Sunni Sky’s Homemade Ice Cream

Summer in Fayetteville calls for a delicious scoop of ice cream! With so many great places to choose from, it’s hard to pick just one. Sunni Sky’s Homemade Ice Cream is a fan favorite and offers an impressive selection of flavors, both dairy, and non-dairy, including some unique options. You can sample the 125+ varieties before you commit to your favorite – Strawberry Cheesecake, Tiramisu, Chocolate Eclairs, Peach Cobbler, German Chocolate Cake, and Key Lime Pie, all in ice cream form! Generous samples are given, so there’s no need to stick to just one flavor on your first visit – come back again and try something new!

Delicious Homemade Ice Cream and Grill Favorites

For more than 85 years, Yarborough’s has been a beacon of deliciousness in downtown Sanford. Its red-and-white-striped awning and eye-catching 3-D cow mural attract attention from far and wide – and for good reason! Inside, visitors can find the best homemade ice cream around, with year-round favorites and seasonal flavors made with local fruit. If you’re looking for something to eat, their grill has got you covered with burgers, hot dogs, fries, and a legendary fried bologna sandwich.

The Mad Hatters Ice Cream

Gillis Hill Farm has been a beloved destination for visitors for over 250 years, offering tours of the farm and the opportunity to feed the animals. In 2006, they added The Mad Hatters Ice Cream to their offerings, with homemade waffle cones and flavors such as Chesire Cat, Unbirthday Cake, and Queen of Hearts, as well as Latin-influenced flavors like Gansito, lucuma, tequila and lime sorbet, and chamoy-topped mangonadas. It is a truly magical experience that has become a must-see destination for locals and tourists alike.

Authentic Soda Fountain Experience & Homemade Ice Cream

The Dewberry Deli in Cameron is a must-visit destination for an authentic soda fountain experience. It’s located downstairs from an antique store and offers a variety of treats, such as sandwiches, banana splits, and a dewberry cobbler topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. For a genuine old-school experience, Smith Farm in Coats is the perfect place to go. Featuring wood-churned homemade ice cream, as well as a play area for kids, Smith Farm always has something new to offer with their weekly flavor specials – just check out their Instagram or Facebook page to find out what it is!

Fayetteville offers something for everyone when it comes to ice cream, with an array of styles and flavors from Sunni Sky’s Homemade Ice Cream, Yarborough’s legendary fried bologna sandwich, and the delightful Mad Hatters Ice Cream at Gillis Hill Farm. Each offers a unique experience that will make every visitor wish to come back again and again. Whether you’re in the mood for traditional favorites or are looking for something fresh and exciting, Fayetteville is the perfect place to satisfy your ice cream craving.